It has been a great summer for movies based on comic-books, and it has culminated with this weekend’s release of The Dark Knight. I have to admit that I was skeptical of the hype surrounding Heath Ledger’s portrayal of The Joker. I assumed that early screeners and critics were being overly exuberant on account of the late actor’s untimely demise. However, after seeing The Dark Knight, I can honestly say that Ledger’s performance is one of the best I’ve seen so far this year. Is it Oscar-worthy? Yes, I’d have to say that, out of what we’ve seen in 2008, it is probably on the top of my list. Will he be nominated? Possibly, but you just never know with these things. We still have half the year to go, and the movie studios typically save their big dramatic pieces (the ones that tend to get nominated) for the holiday movie season. Who knows what great performances lay in wait for us? Furthermore, by the time the award season rolls around next year, the Academy may have forgotten all about poor Heath’s brilliant performance. Only time will tell.
Anyway, I would have to say that The Dark Knight is a major success. It’s not your typical flashy comic-book hero movie. It is a gripping crime drama with a dynamite ensemble cast. And though Heath Ledger shines brightly, his supporting cast members are no slouches. The story is compelling and relatively believable. One of my favorite things about the two Christopher Nolan Batman epics is that the villains are not the “over-the-top” cartoon characters pulled directly from the pages of the comics. They are much more realistic and, therefore, scarier. And the motivations for them becoming what they have become are entirely believable.
The Dark Knight is ultimately the story of a tragic love triangle… actually, I guess it’s a love quadrilateral. Bruce Wayne/Batman loves Rachel Dawes. Harvey Dent loves Rachel too. Then there’s The Joker, who, in his twisted way, loves Batman. He can’t bring himself to eliminate Batman because, in his own words, Batman “completes” him. It’s bloody brilliant. And its tragic climax is downright Shakespearean (or at least The Empire Strikes Back). If you don’t understand, after seeing it, why this film is so great, there is probably something wrong with you. It has everything that makes a really great movie: good story, good writing, great performances.
I never thought I’d see a year where my three top favorite films would all be comic-book movies. It’s nice that somebody is finally getting it right.